Editor's Note: Alternate Outcomes is an article series that examines alternative outcomes to specific divergent points in historical e...
Editor's Note: Alternate Outcomes is an article series that examines alternative outcomes to specific divergent points in historical events. It explores the 'what ifs' when a historical event goes to a different route. All the scenarios discussed here did not happen and are just mere educational speculations of what might have been.
In the vast tapestry of history, there are moments when a seemingly insignificant event can set in motion a chain of consequences that reshape the course of nations. Such is the case with the story of Gomburza, three Filipino priests whose execution in 1872 ignited a fervent call for change in the Philippines. But what if, by some twist of fate, the execution never occurred? What if the butterfly flapped its wings differently, altering the course of history? In this alternate history, we'll explore the repercussions of Gomburza's survival and how it shaped a different destiny for the Spanish East Indies.
The Martyrdom That Never Was
In our alternate timeline, on the fateful day of February 17, 1872, the colonial authorities in the Philippines decided not to execute Fathers Mariano Gómez, José Burgos, and Jacinto Zamora, collectively known as Gomburza. Perhaps it was a change of heart, a shift in political strategy, or an unexpected intervention that spared their lives. Regardless of the reason, the lives of these three priests were no longer in peril.
Gomburza's survival became a symbol of resistance against Spanish colonial rule. The very existence of these priests, who were outspoken critics of the abuses of the colonial administration, inspired countless Filipinos to stand up for their rights and demand reforms. The seeds of revolution, once dormant, began to germinate.
A United Front
The absence of Gomburza's execution meant that the Filipino resistance movements didn't splinter into factions as they did in reality. Instead, they found a common cause in their shared disdain for Spanish colonial rule. Leaders from different regions of the archipelago rallied together, and the Filipino revolutionary movement became more cohesive.
 |
| New leaders have emerged. They advocated for peaceful reforms in the colony. |
In this alternate history, the Katipunan, the secret society that played a pivotal role in the Revolution, developed differently. Its leaders, inspired by the charismatic example of Gomburza, advocated for a peaceful transition to self-rule and reforms within the framework of Spanish rule. The Katipunan, rather than being a militant organization, became a political force pushing for a more equitable relationship with Spain.
Negotiation, Not Conflict
With the Katipunan's peaceful approach, negotiations between Filipino leaders and the Spanish authorities began. These negotiations were challenging, marked by tension and mistrust, but they were not marred by the violence that characterized the actual revolution. The Spanish Crown, recognizing the growing strength of the Filipino movement, was compelled to make concessions.
 |
| Spain loosened its grip on control and allowed greater autonomy in the Philippines |
In 1898, after years of negotiations, the Spanish East Indies gained a significant degree of autonomy within the Spanish Empire. While still under Spanish sovereignty, Filipinos had control over their local affairs, and Spanish abuses were curtailed. Gomburza's legacy of peaceful resistance had borne fruit.
A Different 1898
In our alternate timeline, the Spanish-American War played out differently. With a relatively stable situation in the Spanish East Indies, there was no need for the United States to intervene militarily. Instead, diplomatic negotiations resolved the dispute between Spain and the United States over Cuba.
The colony retained its autonomy within the Spanish Empire as the 19th century drew to a close. The islands became a model colony with a hybrid system, incorporating Filipino traditions and governance structures under Spanish oversight. With that, it renamed itself to Filipinas.
A Unique Trajectory
As the world entered the 20th century, Filipinas maintained their semi-autonomous status within the Spanish Empire. With the outbreak of World War I, the islands played a significant role in supplying manpower and resources to the Spanish war effort. This bolstered the Philippines' standing within the empire.
Over time, a distinct Filipino national identity developed, drawing from the nation's pre-colonial heritage and the cultural exchange with Spain. This identity was further cemented through educational reforms and the promotion of native languages and traditions.
The Unraveling of Empires
As the 20th century progressed, the Spanish Empire faced its own set of challenges. Economic pressures, rising nationalist movements in its other colonies, and the strain of maintaining a vast empire took their toll. However, Filipinas remained an exception, thanks to the unique path forged by Gomburza's survival.
 |
| Dr. Jose Rizal became the first president of Filipinas |
In the 1930s, as other colonial empires crumbled amid global conflicts, Spain recognized the inevitability of decolonization. In a historic moment, Spain and Filipinas negotiated a peaceful transition to full independence, with Filipinas becoming a sovereign nation in 1946, free from colonial rule.
The Echoes of the Past
In this alternate history, the survival of Gomburza set in motion a series of events that led to a more peaceful and negotiated path to Filipino self-rule. Filipinas achieved independence without the bloodshed and destruction of the actual revolution. The legacy of Gomburza, as proponents of peaceful resistance and unity, left an indelible mark on the nation's history.
The butterfly effect, that tiny flutter of wings, reshaped the destiny of an entire nation. While we can only imagine the myriad of other consequences that might have arisen from such a change, one thing is clear: the Philippines of our alternate history emerged as a beacon of hope for peaceful change in a world often marked by conflict and upheaval.
COMMENTS